Today is International Labor Day. Our nations newfound awareness of this day I dont ever remember celebrating or acknowledging this growing up marks the growing influence of what seems to be a new movement in the United States, led mostly by immigrant rights groups. My parents are immigrants, yet in the current debate, I still feel so American. I grew up around immigrants mostly from Hungary but none were illegal. Most were solidly middle class. Though never as American as the blond cheerleaders, I also never felt like an outsider (well, not based on my ethnicity). Then again, my language and my appearance did not signify my immigrant roots.
Teaching in a Latino school in Los Angeles requires me to reassess my identity as an American and as a daughter of immigrants. My awareness of my privilege of my whiteness is more apparent in comparison to the obstacles my students face. As an outsider there, my dark hair and eyes allow me to blend a bit and when I first started students would ask if I am Mexican or Latina. When they realized I wasnt, the assumption jumped to me being a rich, privileged white who lived in Beverly Hills and drove a fancy car. For this, they were determined to make me suffer the guilt of the transgressions of whites against all others. It worked at times. I often wondered, if I spoke Spanish, if I could pass as Latina, floating between the worlds of white Studio City and Latino East LA as most of us code-shift between informal and formal language as we go from home to work. However, I dont, so they must learn to deal with me, as an outsider who is also a part of their community via the school. They have begun to see me as at least an ally, someone who will allow them to speak their minds without judgment and who share my opinions honestly. Thus develops a sense of obligation to each other and seeing ourselves in new ways in light of this new connection.
Yet, as a daughter of immigrants and an educator of immigrants who tries to inspire their activism and claiming of their own voices, why did I feel so reluctant to take part in the rallies and boycotts throughout LA, the country, and the world on this May Day? I felt my not going to work would hurt me more than make a statement. In fact, it was quite a normal day at school. Almost peaceful with room to breathe with only two thirds of the students on campus. Not shopping is not really an issue I only do that about once a week anyway. Still, I did not see myself as having a role in this pageant. Students asked if I was going to the rally. As I answered that I probably would not, I felt a sense of guilt and embarrassment in my hypocrisy. When my carpooling partner said he was going to go to the rally via subway after he dropped me off, I decided to go, both for myself and for my students.
Dressed in my brown corduroy pants and black shirt, without sunglasses or a hat or any of my Hungarian paraphernalia, I could not have been less prepared for a rally. We rode a subway crowded with families and groups of friends in sparkling white shirts, made whiter next to the various shades of brown skin, jet-black silky hair, and liquid black eyes. Unfortunately, the subways in LA have the standing grip bar much higher than in NY, leaving my arm a bit cramped after the slow ride down to MacArthur Park.

The park had the air of holiday. The sun gleamed through the rather clear air as protesters lounged on the green grass surrounding the lake. Observers lined the wall along Wilshire Boulevard. Some played guitars while waiting. Many seemed as if this lounging on a day off was the extent of their protest, and, given the relaxed atmosphere, I am sure everyone would applaud that choice. Something about this reminded me of a massive version of the Hungarian club picnics. Young people held hands and darted in and out of the crowd. Older participants strolled casually or participated from the sidelines waving flags as the procession passed, chanting with the crowd where their feet could not carry them. People smiled and laughed. Si se puede crescendoed the crowd any time a camera, still or video, was within site. No one questioned the presence of my companion and I, obviously not Latinos, particularly when I asked him, who is whiter than I am, to translate some of the chants.
Though I feel strongly about some aspects of this issue and generally support finding humane and fair solutions for those who marched along with me, I did have to wonder about the efficacy of chanting in Spanish for the full rights of U.S. citizenship. At times, I could not help but question my purpose for being there and what is this crowd really saying. Perhaps this is why I do not participate in large activist events I have trouble going along with large crowds and massive sloganized political statements. Yet, I was happy to be there to at least stand up for what parts I believe in, though I know no one else would exactly what that was in the sea of people.

For a protest, the festive and positive tone pleased me. Sure, signs proclaimed disgust with the powers that be. Maid in America was worn on the back of one woman. Send us your tired and poor . . .. WE are your tired and poor captioned a sketch of the Statue of Liberty. The real criminals are in the White House, yelled a neon pink sign. The American flags outnumbered those of Mexico, Brazil, El Salvador, and other countries of origin of the millions of participants. It was patriotic. I was appreciative of all who were there and all who let us pass without incident. Even the little children waving flags and joining in the si se puede chorus that set the beat for our walking seemed to be having fun, showing no signs of weariness or reluctance. More than anger, there was joy and pride in the protesters voices and on their faces. Next to me, a woman held a baby bundled in a soft pink blanket, breastfeeding as she marched. She smiled humbly at me as I smiled back. There was something beautiful about this young mother, glowing with her child attached to her breast as she participated in a moment of unity and voice for and for the daughter she feeds. And the daughter? Perhaps something from that day will implant itself into her subconscious mind and she will be the first Latina president? I felt confident she would be more compassionate than our current president.
After walking with the protesters for about 10 blocks, the sun had heated my black shirt and my squinting eyes grew irritated. We needed to find a subway station to catch the train back home. In Koreatown, where we expected more Asian immigrants to join us but did not see any, we headed up Vermont and back to the San Fernando Valley, on another subway car backed with now sweaty and sleepy protesters.
I never made it to yoga. I cant say I feel any sense of great political efficacy by having been to this rally nor do I have a clearer understanding of the nuances of the immigration laws that are in debate. In fact, they seem a bit cloudier (besides the one that would make felons of illegal immigrants and those who show them any humanitarian aid). I do feel honored to have witnessed what I believe to be the beginning of a new movement and chapter in American social and political history (positive or destructive will remain to be seen). Moreover, I did gain of sense of connectedness to this issue, sensing, though it is not obvious, that I do have a place in this movement and in this debate. Despite what the protesters faces would leave us to conclude, I was reminded that immigrant is not equal to Mexican. Immigrant is my Hungarian parents and my companions Canadian heritage and really, even more so, anyone who has any roots outside of the Indian heritage of this land. Ive heard it said that the pilgrims are the original illegal immigrants. Nice rhetoric, but how does that inform the decisions we must make today?